ReplacementHQ/How we verify

How we verify

An answer is verified when the printer maker's own page was opened and the quoted words appear on it. Retailer listings, forums, reviews and AI summaries never verify.Verification is not physical testing: we have not physically tested these printers.

What counts

Only the maker's documents count: product pages, wiki pages and notices published by the maker. Each answer shows the page, the date we opened it and a quotation of 25 words or fewer from that page. If a maker's page changes or disappears, the answer is re-checked.

The five states

  • Verified. The maker's page for that printer and claim was opened and quoted. Shown with a tick and the date.
  • Maker states. The maker says it but not in our wording. Shown without a tick.
  • Under review. The maker's pages disagree, or a credible correction is open. Shown in amber, and no seller link appears.
  • Not verified. Never shown as an answer. Absence of evidence is not turned into a verdict.
  • Does not fit or not recommended. A verified negative, in the maker's own words.

Which printers are published

A printer is published only when at least 80% of the answers we intend to publish for it are verified. The intended list is fixed in advance and unverified answers stay in the count.

Verified answers per printer
PrinterStatusVerified
Bambu Lab A1Current13 of 13
Bambu Lab A1 miniCurrent13 of 13
Bambu Lab P1SCurrent13 of 13
Bambu Lab H2DCurrent13 of 13
Bambu Lab X1 Carbon (X1C)Legacy13 of 13
Original Prusa MK4SCurrent12 of 12

Answers were restated in the maker's own words where the maker states the fact differently from how we first wrote it. No answer was dropped from the count to lift a printer over the line.

Sources

What this is not

It is not a physical test. We do not say a part was tested, measured or bought by us. A verified answer means the maker says so; it does not mean a particular spool, nozzle or batch will behave that way.

How we make money

We do not sell anything. Seller links appear only after a verified answer, are labelled as affiliate links, and are removed while a credible correction is open. There are no seller links yet. See the affiliate disclosure.

Corrections

Every page shows when it was last checked. If something is wrong, report it. Credible reports are logged in public and the affected answer is held until it is resolved.